Summary
Quotations play a crucial role in academic and scientific writing, but using them effectively requires much more than simply inserting an author’s words into your text. Direct quotations carry intellectual weight: they provide evidence, illustrate points with precision and demonstrate your engagement with the scholarship surrounding your topic. However, to be genuinely persuasive, quotations must be handled with accuracy, context and clear purpose.
This expanded guide explains how to adjust quotations responsibly and ethically — for example, by marking omissions with ellipses or clarifications with square brackets — while emphasising the importance of preserving the original author’s meaning. It also explores when these adjustments are appropriate, which disciplinary conventions require stricter marking, and how to maintain transparency in your treatment of quoted material.
Equally important is your ability to introduce each quotation effectively. A sentence or two of contextualisation helps readers understand why the quoted material matters, who is speaking and how it connects to your research argument. Without such introduction, quotations can appear abrupt, interrupt the flow of your writing or leave readers uncertain about their significance.
Following each quotation, your discussion — whether brief or extended — must guide readers toward the insight you want them to gain. Strong commentary analyses the quotation’s meaning, identifies key ideas or nuances and explains its relationship to your broader argument or findings. A well-chosen quotation accompanied by thoughtful interpretation can strengthen your thesis far more effectively than a long extract presented without explanation.
Together, these practices — adjusting responsibly, introducing clearly and discussing analytically — ensure that quotations contribute meaningfully to your work. They demonstrate rigorous scholarship, strengthen your argument and help produce a polished, professional thesis or dissertation that examiners will recognise as careful and credible.
📖 Full Length Article (Click to collapse)
Quotations in Theses and Dissertations: How to Use and Explain Them
Quotations are a powerful scholarly tool. They allow you to incorporate authoritative statements, definitions and interpretations into your own writing, giving depth to your argument and demonstrating that your work is grounded in established research. Whether you are analysing literature, reporting scientific findings or discussing conceptual debates, quotations enable you to place your project in conversation with the broader academic community.
Yet quotations must be handled with great care. Simply inserting someone else’s words into your text does not automatically strengthen your argument. How you introduce, modify and discuss each quotation determines whether it enhances or weakens your work. Successful integration requires clarity, accuracy and thoughtful engagement — the cornerstones of strong academic writing.
1. When and Why Quotations May Need Adjustment
In most cases, quotations should be reproduced exactly as they appear in the original source. The authority of a quotation lies in its precise wording, so changes should be avoided whenever possible. However, small adjustments may occasionally be necessary to integrate a quotation smoothly into your own prose or to clarify its meaning for your readers.
For example, you may need to change a capital letter to lowercase if a quotation appears mid-sentence, or insert a clarifying noun when a pronoun like “he” or “they” would otherwise create ambiguity. You might also omit sections of a long passage to focus on the parts most relevant to your argument. These adjustments help quotations function grammatically and logically within your writing.
It is important to stress that no adjustment should ever alter the original author’s meaning. Any change that risks distorting the source — even subtly — must be avoided. In such cases, consider paraphrasing instead or restructuring your own sentence to accommodate the quotation unchanged.
2. How to Mark Additions and Omissions Correctly
Academic conventions for marking modified quotations are widely accepted. Additions or clarifications appear within square brackets, and omissions are signalled with an ellipsis (…). These practices ensure transparency and help readers understand how your version differs from the original.
Square brackets allow you to add explanatory words or adjust minor grammatical features without misleading your audience. For example:
“The committee determined that [the revised methodology] would yield more reliable results.”
The bracketed phrase clarifies the intended subject without altering the meaning. Similarly, ellipses are used to indicate omitted text:
“The researchers emphasised the need for further trials…to verify the consistency of the findings.”
However, omissions must be made ethically. Removing key clauses that alter the author’s meaning or context is unacceptable and constitutes misrepresentation. Examiners are particularly alert to irresponsible use of ellipses, especially in thesis-level work.
3. Disciplinary Standards and Style Guide Requirements
Different academic fields approach quotation adjustments with varying levels of strictness. Disciplines such as history, literature and law often require every modification — even changes in punctuation — to be marked. Meanwhile, some scientific styles allow minor adjustments (such as changing case or punctuation) without formal markers.
To ensure compliance, always consult your:
- departmental dissertation guidelines,
- institution’s formatting manual,
- required style guide (APA, MLA, Chicago, etc.),
- supervisor or committee.
When uncertain, it is safer to indicate the adjustment. Consistency across your thesis is essential, and transparent marking demonstrates responsible scholarship.
4. Why Every Quotation Needs an Introduction
A common mistake in postgraduate writing is the “dropped quotation” — a line of text inserted abruptly with no explanation. This leaves your readers guessing why the quotation matters or how it supports your point. Even if the meaning seems obvious to you, it may not be obvious to others.
A strong introduction accomplishes several goals. It identifies the source, explains the context and signals the purpose of the quotation. For instance:
As Johnson (2018) argues in her critique of public health communication, “clarity must precede persuasion.”
This introduction does more than lead into a quotation. It frames the quoted material, aligns it with your argument and guides the reader to interpret it in the way you intend.
5. Discussing Quotations: Moving from Evidence to Argument
Presenting a quotation is only the first step. The heart of scholarly writing lies in your analysis. After quoting, you must explain what the passage means, why it matters and how it strengthens your argument. Examiners often comment that underdeveloped discussion weakens otherwise strong dissertations.
Your commentary should do at least one of the following:
- clarify the quotation’s meaning,
- explain how it supports your claim,
- highlight key words or phrases,
- show how it relates to other evidence,
- evaluate the strength of the quoted argument,
- signal limitations or counterarguments when relevant.
Without such discussion, quotations remain surface-level and risk appearing decorative rather than analytical. Remember: your reader should never be left to interpret a quotation alone. It is your job to guide them.
6. Ensuring Accuracy and Relevance in Quotation Use
A well-chosen quotation is concise, relevant and effectively linked to your research objective. Longer quotations may be necessary for textual analysis or conceptual argument, but in most disciplines they can interrupt the flow of your writing if used excessively.
Before including a quotation, ask yourself:
• Does this quotation add something essential?
• Could a paraphrase express the idea more efficiently?
• Is the passage too long or unfocused?
• Do I discuss it adequately afterwards?
Precision and purpose are key. One short, relevant quotation can strengthen your argument far more than several long ones used without sufficient analysis.
7. Ethical Responsibilities When Quoting
Responsible quotation use is part of academic integrity. Altering quoted material in a way that misrepresents the source, omitting key information or failing to cite accurately can lead to serious consequences, including corrections, resubmission requests or allegations of misconduct.
Accuracy, transparency and clear citation protect your scholarly credibility. They also help readers verify your claims and understand the foundations of your argument.
8. Conclusion
Effective quotation use requires more than selecting striking passages. It relies on thoughtful adjustment, careful introduction and detailed discussion. When these elements are handled well, quotations support your argument, demonstrate your scholarly depth and strengthen the overall structure of your thesis.
For additional help ensuring clarity, accuracy and strong integration of quotations in your dissertation, our professional dissertation proofreading service can provide detailed support at any stage of your academic writing.
