Summary
“Lie, lie, lay” are three look-alike verbs that cause look-alike mistakes—especially in theses and dissertations. English has two different lie verbs (to tell an untruth; to recline) plus the transitive lay (to put/place something). Each has its own past tense and past participle: lie (deceive) → lied, lied; lie (recline) → lay, lain; lay (put) → laid, laid. The most common academic errors are writing “he lied down” (should be “lay down”) and “has laid down” for the reclining sense (should be “has lain down”).
Key points: (1) Decide whether the verb takes an object—if “something” is being placed, use lay/laid. (2) For reclining with no object, use lie/lay/lain. (3) For telling an untruth, use lie/lied/lied. (4) In formal writing, avoid colloquial blends (“I was laying on the sofa” when you mean lying). (5) Use the tables, tests, and examples below to check every instance before submission.
Bottom line: objects take lay/laid; bodies recline with lie/lay/lain; untruths use lie/lied/lied. A quick object test and a glance at the conjugation tables will keep your thesis error-free.
📖 Full Length (Click to collapse)
Lie, Lie and Lay: Three Challenging English Verbs and How To Use Them Properly in Your Thesis or Dissertation
A precise, dissertation-safe guide with tables, tests, and examples
Among the most persistent grammar problems in formal academic prose is the trio lie, lie, and lay. The difficulty is not just that two of the verbs share a spelling; it is that their past forms overlap confusingly in sound and appearance (lay is both a base form and a past form). In theses and dissertations—where precision is non-negotiable—these small slips can distract examiners and undermine readers’ confidence. This guide sorts the three verbs by meaning, shows how they conjugate, and gives practical tests to ensure you choose the right form every time.
1) Meanings and Transitivity: the core distinction
- lie (deceive): “to tell an untruth.” Intransitive—no direct object. He lied about the data.
- lie (recline): “to rest in a flat position; to be situated.” Intransitive. The participants lie on the mat.
- lay (put/place): “to put or set something down.” Transitive—requires a direct object. She lays the device on the bench.
2) Conjugation tables (print-worthy)
| Verb | Meaning | Base | 3rd sg. pres. | Past (simple) | Past participle | Present participle | Object? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| lie | tell an untruth | lie | lies | lied | lied | lying | No |
| lie | recline / be situated | lie | lies | lay | lain | lying | No |
| lay | put / place | lay | lays | laid | laid | laying | Yes |
3) Core examples (formal academic tone)
a) Lie (deceive): lied, lied
- Present: “The suspect lies about prior exposure.”
- Past: “The participant lied on the screening form.”
- Perfect: “They have lied in previous statements.”
- Progressive: “He was lying during the interview.”
b) Lie (recline): lay, lain
- Present: “Subjects lie supine for 10 minutes.”
- Past: “After exertion, each athlete lay on the mat.”
- Perfect: “The specimens have lain in storage since 2020.”
- Progressive: “The patient is lying still during imaging.”
Caution
✗ “He lied down to rest.” → Wrong for reclining.
✓ “He lay down to rest.”
✗ “He has laid down for an hour.” → Wrong for reclining.
✓ “He has lain down for an hour.”
c) Lay (put/place): laid, laid
- Present: “The researcher lays the sensor on the forearm.”
- Past: “We laid the quadrats at 2-m intervals.”
- Perfect: “The team has laid new fibre-optic cable.”
- Progressive: “They are laying the foundations for Phase 2.”
4) Why errors occur (and how to neutralise them)
- Overlap of forms: lay is the past of lie (recline) and the base of lay (put). Solution: run the object test. If an object follows, use lay/laid.
- Colloquial drift: speech often uses “lay” for “lie” (“I was laying on the sofa”). In formal writing, restore the standard form: “I was lying.”
- Participle confusion: lain is rare outside formal prose. When you use a perfect form for reclining, prefer “has lain,” never “has laid” or “has lied.”
5) Decision tools: two fast tests
- Replace with “put.” If “put” makes sense, you need lay/laid (transitive). “She ___ the samples on ice.” → “She put the samples…” → laid.
- Try adding an object. If adding an object breaks the sentence, you need lie/lay/lain. “The patient ___ down.” (No object) → lay.
6) Advanced notes for dissertations
- Non-literal uses: In academic style, avoid figurative “lie”/“lay” unless the field convention permits. Prefer precise verbs: “The responsibility rests with the council,” “The data are located in…”
- Passive voice: Transitive lay forms a natural passive: “The grid was laid last year.” Intransitive lie (recline) cannot be passivised.
- Regional variation: Some dialects accept “I was laying down” informally. Formal scholarly prose requires “I was lying down.”
7) Common thesis sentences—before/after
| Problematic | Corrected | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| “Participants were laying supine for 15 minutes.” | “Participants were lying supine for 15 minutes.” | Recline → intransitive lie progressive. |
| “Each subject has laid still during scanning.” | “Each subject has lain still during scanning.” | Perfect of lie (recline) → lain. |
| “We lay the apparatus on the platform yesterday.” | “We laid the apparatus on the platform yesterday.” | Past of transitive lay is laid. |
| “The official lied on the bench to recover.” | “The official lay on the bench to recover.” | Not deception; reclining. |
8) Mini-drills (answers below)
- The patient ___ down while the electrodes were attached. (past)
- Please ___ the sterile instruments on the tray. (base)
- Several artefacts have ___ undisturbed since excavation. (past participle)
- The witness ___ about prior convictions. (past)
- The assistant is ___ the cables along the wall. (present participle)
- At baseline, participants ___ supine for five minutes. (present)
Show answers
- lay (recline past of lie)
- lay (transitive base form)
- lain (past participle of lie recline)
- lied (past of lie deceive)
- laying (present participle of transitive lay)
- lie (present of intransitive lie)
9) Quick reference cards (copy into your style sheet)
Recline (no object): lie — lay — lain — lying.
Put/place (takes object): lay — laid — laid — laying.
Deceive: lie — lied — lied — lying.
10) Frequent questions
Q: Can “lie” (recline) take an object? A: No. If an object follows, you need lay. “She lay the samples on ice” (put/place). “She lay down” (recline) has no object.
Q: Is “has laid” ever correct? A: Yes—but only for lay (put/place): “The team has laid markers along the transect.” It is not correct for reclining; use “has lain.”
Q: What about “lay” as a noun/adjective (layperson, laity)? A: Different word family—irrelevant to the verb distinction in academic prose.
11) Style guidance for theses/dissertations
- Be consistent with tense: Methods sections typically use past tense (“participants lay supine”), whereas present tense is fine for general truths (“cells lie within the matrix”).
- Avoid ambiguity: If both senses might be read, rephrase: “The samples were placed” instead of “The samples were laid,” if your supervisor prefers agentless passive.
- Proofread systematically: Search your document for “lay,” “laid,” “lain,” “lied,” and “lying.” Confirm each against the object test and the tables.
12) Editing checklist (final pass)
- Every lay/laid has a direct object explicitly present or clearly implied (“lay the cables,” not “lay down” unless an object follows).
- Every instance of reclining uses lie/lay/lain (no object); no “lied down / has laid down” errors remain.
- Every instance meaning “tell an untruth” uses lied/has lied.
- Progressive forms are correct: “is lying,” not “is laying,” unless placing an object.
13) Polished examples for common sections
Methods (STEM)
Participants lay supine for five minutes prior to venipuncture. The technician then laid a warm pack over the antecubital fossa.
Humanities
The folio lies at the intersection of devotional and political discourse; the historiographer lied about sources only in the later tract.
Social sciences
All devices were laid on a non-conductive surface, and participants lay quietly during calibration.
14) Memory hooks (choose one)
- Recline = no object = lie: “I lie on the bed today; yesterday I lay; many times I have lain.”
- Place = object = lay: “I lay the book today; yesterday I laid it; many times I have laid it.”
- Untruth = lie/lied/lied: “He lied to the committee.”
Why Our Editing and Proofreading Services?
At Proof-Reading-Service.com we offer rigorous journal article editing, meticulous dissertation proofreading and comprehensive online proofreading services by native-English, postgraduate-qualified editors across disciplines. Our manuscript editing specialists routinely correct high-visibility verb errors (including lie/lay confusions), ensure compliance with house style, and polish grammar, punctuation and usage so your research reads as precisely as it was conducted.
Conclusion
For all their reputation as “little” words, lie and lay can topple the polish of an otherwise excellent thesis. The fix is mechanical: check transitivity, consult the tables, and apply the object test. If you are describing placement, choose lay/laid; if you are describing reclining, choose lie/lay/lain; if you are describing deception, choose lie/lied/lied. With those habits in place, your prose will remain as exact as your methodology—and your examiners will stay focused on your ideas, not your irregular verbs.
