How To Identify a Doctor No Peer Review of a Journal Paper

How To Identify a Doctor No Peer Review of a Journal Paper
Have you ever submitted an article to a reputable scientific journal only to have the paper rejected or sent back for major or even impossible revisions after peer review for reasons that do not make sense to you? Perhaps your article was rejected without any valid explanation. Perhaps there were detailed criticisms that seemed excessive or inappropriate. Perhaps the good comments of reviewers seemed to outweigh the bad, yet the paper was unnecessarily delayed or simply not accepted. It may be that you were a victim of a ‘Doctor No’ reviewer who instead of using the review process to improve articles and advance science, uses it to prevent the publication of good papers containing valuable research simply to satisfy personal ambitions and resentments. Information on classic Doctor No reviewing techniques can be found at the Knoepfler blog:
Increase Your Chances of Getting Published
Particularly troubling is the thought that some journal editors may feel unable to contradict the opinions of high-profile scientists even when their reviews are unfair and silence valid and useful research. Forewarned is forearmed, however, and if you know that your chances of getting a Doctor No reviewer is doubled when you submit to the high-impact journals that publish the articles of those well-known scientists, you can be prepared – prepared for what might be bad news, of course, but prepared also to submit a paper that is so well researched and carefully written that Doctor No will at least find it difficult to criticise. This does not correct the larger problem or compensate for prolonged suffering among those in need of the benefits provided by scientific progress, but it does focus the attention of the researcher on his or her own work, which is always where your focus should land first when receiving negative comments from peer reviewers. This is to say that it is wise not to begin by assuming that a Doctor No has applied the scalpel to your writing, and only after serious consideration that aspires to the objectivity some reviewers obviously lack should you ignore or reject the feedback reviewers have offered on your work.

The Knoepfler blog suggests that open rather than blind reviews may be a potential solution to the Doctor No problem, but also mentions the possibility of retaliation on the part of angry authors against peer reviewers in an open review scenario. Comments on experiments with open peer reviewing can be found at There, another disturbing possibility is noted: an unscrupulous Doctor No reviewer may even use the opportunity of reviewing your paper to glean the knowledge needed to publish something similar after ensuring that your work has been rejected or its publication significantly delayed. Would this be less likely to happen if you knew the identity of the reviewer? Quite possibly, but it seems that there is no easy solution to the reviewing problem, and certainly there is far more than publication and career success at stake here.

Why Our Editing and Proofreading Services?
At we pride ourselves on our large and extremely dedicated team of academic and scientific professionals. Our proofreaders and editors are highly educated native speakers of English and their areas of specialisation range so widely that we are able to help our clients improve and perfect all kinds of research manuscripts for successful publication. Many members of our team work predominantly on articles intended for publication in scholarly journals, ensuring that formatting and references conform to author guidelines with precision and correcting grammar, punctuation, spelling and simple typing errors so that our customers are able to report their research in the clear and accurate ways required to impress acquisitions editors and earn publication.

Our editing services for authors of scientific papers and books are especially popular, but we have the experience and expertise to proofread and edit books in every scholarly discipline as well as beyond them, and some of our carefully trained proofreaders and editors work exclusively on helping students improve the formatting and language of their theses and dissertations. Whether you are preparing a conference paper for presentation or publicationpolishing a professional report to share with your colleagues, or tackling the daunting task of editing and perfecting any kind of academic or scientific document, a qualified member of our expert team can provide invaluable assistance and give you greater confidence in your written work. Our translation services for scientific and academic documents have also proven immensely helpful for many of our international clients.

topbanner errow